Applicant questions selection process

By Mike Odom
Staff Writer
Posted 5/26/09

FAIRHOPE, Ala. — Some people seeking to have Capt. Steve Griffis appointed police chief have not stated why they thought the selection process was unfair, but one candidate for the job, who did not make the list of finalists, has stated with …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Subscribe to continue reading. Already a subscriber? Sign in

Local reporters keeping you informed across the Alabama Gulf Coast.

You can cancel anytime.
 

Please log in to continue

Log in

Applicant questions selection process

Posted

FAIRHOPE, Ala. — Some people seeking to have Capt. Steve Griffis appointed police chief have not stated why they thought the selection process was unfair, but one candidate for the job, who did not make the list of finalists, has stated with specificity why he thinks the process was flawed.

In a seven-page letter that Doug Lamplugh submitted to the City Council on May 18, he sets out his case for why the process should be questioned.

“I’m writing this letter to express my dissatisfaction with the police chief search process that has occurred so far,” Lamplugh states in the first paragraph of his May 18 letter. “Yes, I was a candidate for the position, but my goal in writing this letter is to (ensure) that council knows the details of the process and why it has been a failure.”

Lamplugh was ranked 60th by the search committee from a list of 116 initial applicants.

The committee used a rubric provided by the Human Resources Department which addressed various criteria for the job to guide the selection process, according to city records and HR Administrator Rhonda White.

However, Lamplugh’s letter states that his review of some of the documents led him to the conclusion that the overall process was flawed. He pointed to the fact that one member, Valerie Chaney, did not participate in the ranking of the original 116, and that Mayor Tim Kant also did not directly participate in all aspects of that ranking by delegating it to staff.

He also wrote that there was a lack of explanation of law enforcement in general to the committee, from which he concluded that the committee was ill-equipped to adequately evaluate and compare the range and type of law enforcement experience detailed by those who applied for the job.

But possibly Lamplugh’s most serious accusations of the process being flawed or unfair are aimed at Councilman Dan Stankoski, who chaired the council’s search efforts, selected the committee and served as a member. It was also Stankoski who recommended to the council, based on his review, that it not reappoint Mike Comalander to the chief job.

“One thing I’m certain of after spending time reviewing the process, Dan Stankoski came into this process with an agenda,” Lamplugh wrote. “He wanted someone from outside Fairhope who had no connection with the Fairhope Police Department, or he wanted someone he personally knew and agreed with his agenda. His corruption of the grading process, in my opinion, is far more egregious that what Mayor Tim Kant is accused of.”

At an April 7 meeting of the search committee, Kant said he instructed city staff to whom he delegated his duty to rank the candidates, to give all but a small group of candidates zeros, according to the minutes approved last week.

“He (Kant) replied that she (Human Resources Administrator Rhonda White) didn’t change all of the other scores to a zero as he requested, and had she done that then the top 25 would indeed be different,” the April 7 minutes state.

After the May 11 council meeting, Kant confirmed that he made that statement.

“I was appalled when I read that council member Stankoski scored me a 3 (on a 1-10 scale),” Lamplugh wrote. “But if I am appalled, Capt. Steve Griffis should be livid. Council member Stankoski gave Capt. Griffis a (zero). I’m not sure how an applicant that has submitted (an) application and resume scores a (zero), unless a bias is there. This rating was obviously not based on the resume and application package.”

According to city records, Lamplugh and Griffis received the following ratings from committee members:

•Lamplugh: Bob Callahan (4), Pam Caudill (3), Valerie Chaney (did not rank), Vann Saltz (3), Rick Wilson (6), Stankoski (3) and Kant (7).

•Griffis: Callahan (7), Caudill (3), Chaney (did not rank), Saltz (7), Wilson (7), Stankoski (0) and Kant (10).

Griffis ranked 30th overall, and interim Police Chief Terry Sanders ranked 11th overall.

Sanders received these votes from the committee: Callahan (2), Caudill (3), Chaney (did not rank), Saltz (7), Wilson (9), Stankoski (9) and Kant (9).

Although Sanders did not make the top 10 list all of whom received phone interviews, the council added his name at the May 11 council meeting to the list of five finalists.

There were 116 applicants for the police chief job in Fairhope.

Ten of those candidates received zeros from all seven search committee members, presumably because they did not meet the minimum requirements for the position such as a college degree. One other applicant received zeros from all committee members except one.

But Stankoski’s rating of Griffis with a zero, was the only other zero given by any committee member of any candidate.

Contacted Tuesday morning, Stankoski said the applications were a guide for the committee’s ranking of applicants but that other information could be used. He would not specify what that other information was.

“I’ll let my scores speak for themselves,” Stankoski said about this rating of applicants. He would not offer any other explanation for why he gave a zero to Griffis.

Editor’s note: This story was written before the May 26 City Council meeting at which Lamplugh and other Griffis supporters were expected to speak. Unless the council changed its schedule or any other selection procedures, six finalists will be interviewed in an open meeting setting on Saturday, June 20.