Verbena Avenue man says he started ‘battle’

By Bob Morgan
Posted 10/21/08

FOLEY, Ala. — Fred Eastwood said he started the Battle of Mobile Bay. Not the historical battle that took place during the American Civil War, but the one that has turned into a brouhaha over the ownership of the painting by the same …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Subscribe to continue reading. Already a subscriber? Sign in

Local reporters keeping you informed across the Alabama Gulf Coast.

You can cancel anytime.
 

Please log in to continue

Log in

Verbena Avenue man says he started ‘battle’

Posted

FOLEY, Ala. — Fred Eastwood said he started the Battle of Mobile Bay. Not the historical battle that took place during the American Civil War, but the one that has turned into a brouhaha over the ownership of the painting by the same name.

Eastwood, who lives on Verbena Avenue, addressed himself just that way at Monday’s Foley City Council meeting - as the guy who got the current controversy going concerning who actually owns the huge painting valued at $200,000.

During visitor comments at the conclusion of the council meeting, Eastwood addressed the mayor and council concerning the future of the painting that was originally given as a gift to the city years ago by former mayor Arthur Holk.

Mayor John Koniar, in addressing Eastwood, said the painting has an “unknown future at this time.”

Koniar said the city had received notice that day of a lawsuit against the city by Holk over ownership of the painting that once hung in the Grand Hotel on the Eastern Shore. Koniar said he hadn’t had time to read the paperwork concerning the lawsuit.

“In limbo,” is the way Koniar described the issue of the painting and its future. It will first have to be determined who owns the painting — the City of Foley or Holk, Koniar said.

Eastwood said he joined the Foley Senior Center when he retired. That’s when he saw the painting.

“In the director’s office, it was setting against the wall on the floor with tables and chairs setting in front of it,” Eastwood said during an interview following Monday’s council meeting.

He instantly recognized it, he said.

He then got in touch with Jim Mitchell, a historian who lives in the Fairhope area, and told him what he had found, Eastwood said.

“We were all surprised and everything,” Eastwood said.

“There are certain people in the city that want, let’s say, sidewalks or new police cars or whatever, and when they found out it (the painting) was worth money they instantly wanted to sell it.”

Eastwood said he wants the painting to stay here, meaning in Baldwin County at Fort Morgan, in Foley, or in the County Archives in Bay Minette, where Eastwood said the painting could be loaned out to museums.

Asked if he has talked to people about the painting and gotten their feelings on the subject, Eastwood said he had. Asked if he had a feel for what people want to see happen to the painting, he answered in the affirmative.

“I have a real good feel, especially from the older people like myself. They definitely don’t want it to leave. The only people who want to sell (it) are people who will benefit in the city.”

Mitchell, a member of the Baldwin County Historical Development Commission, said, speaking for himself, he would like to see the painting stay in Baldwin County. He said in conversations with Holk, the former mayor said he gave it on loan to the city for it to go in Foley Public Library, where the painting hung for a number of years. Over the years, the painting was even relegated to what Mitchell called a utility “line shed.”

The county has a solution to Foley’s problems where the painting is concerned, Mitchell said during an interview Tuesday morning. That’s the Baldwin County Archives, he said, where the painting could be stored, maintained and kept.

“If the biggest problem is insuring it, give it or loan it to the County Archives,” Mitchell said, a reference to Foley City Council’s Sept. 15, 2008, meeting in which it was noted it would take $3,600 annually to insure the painting that most recently has hung in the conference room at Foley City Hall. It was at that same meeting that the council agreed to sell the painting.

The Baldwin County Historical Development Commission consists of 12 members, and while Mitchell said they had “chatted” about the painting, the committee founded in 1978 as an arm of Baldwin County government, doesn’t “have a horse in this race,” he said. They hold no sway with any of the parties involved, he said.

BCHDC helps preserve the history of Baldwin County through architectural and historical sites, such as homes, districts, schools and churches, Mitchell said. They also work with Fort Morgan and the Alabama Historical Commission, he said.

Mitchell called the painting a “historically important piece” since it commemorates the “largest naval battle on the North American continent bar none.”

The painting’s significance locally is especially great with the county’s bicentennial coming up, Mitchell said.

Eastwood said he wouldn’t want to see the painting sold to somebody in New Orleans and from there it end up going to New York, Washington or Philadelphia, not when historical entities locally “have the ways and means to bring it back to pristine condition.”

The city was at one point considering a proposal from a New Orleans company that specializes in selling pieces of artwork.

Attempts to reach Arthur Holk for comment on Tuesday morning proved unsuccessful.